Top 24+ Medical Malpractice Insurance Companies for Doctors in 2024 (USA)

Table of Contents

In the ever-evolving world of healthcare, doctors and medical professionals face not only the immense responsibility of patient care, but also the risk of potential lawsuits. Medical malpractice is a serious concern, and doctors need reliable protection to safeguard their careers and finances. That’s where medical malpractice insurance comes into play.

In this article, we will dive into the top 24+ medical malpractice insurance companies for doctors in the USA in 2024. These insurance providers offer comprehensive coverage plans tailored specifically to the unique needs of medical professionals. From solo practitioners to large medical groups, we will explore the insurance companies that provide the best protection in case of a medical malpractice claims.


With an emphasis on reputation, coverage options, affordability, and customer satisfaction, we will assess each insurance company’s offerings, comparing their features and benefits. Whether you are a seasoned physician or just starting your medical career, this guide will help you make an informed decision when selecting the 
best medical malpractice insurance provider for your needs.

Stay ahead of the game and ensure your peace of mind by choosing the right medical malpractice insurance company. Let’s dive in!

Top Medical Malpractice Insurance Companies in the USA

  1. The Doctors Company (TDC): Founded during a malpractice crisis, The Doctors Company (TDC) is a physician-owned carrier dedicated to advocating for doctors. Known for its strong support of physician interests.
  2. MedPro Group: Owned by Berkshire Hathaway, MedPro Group stands out for its remarkable financial strength and stability.MedPro Group offers robust medical malpractice insurance, leveraging its extensive resources to ensure exceptional protection and support for healthcare professionals.
  3. PLI Consultants: PLI Consultants specializes in providing tailored medical malpractice insurance solutions for healthcare professionals. Known for their client-centric approach, PLI Consultants focuses on understanding the unique needs of their clients and delivering customized coverage that addresses specific risks and liabilities.
  4. Coverys: Coverys is a group of carriers offering comprehensive medical malpractice coverage across the nation. Coverys is recognized for its broad reach and extensive risk management services, making it a dependable choice for healthcare providers seeking extensive insurance solutions.
  5. Admiral Insurance Company: Known for offering competitive rates and a variety of coverage options. Admiral is a solid choice for healthcare professionals looking for flexible and cost-effective medical malpractice insurance solutions.
  6. ISMIE Mutual: ISMIE Mutual is a doctor-owned and governed company focusing on patient safety and risk management programs. Its commitment to enhancing healthcare practices through education and support makes it a trusted provider for medical professionals seeking comprehensive liability coverage.
  7. MagMutual Insurance Company: As the largest mutual insurer of physicians, MagMutual Insurance Company is renowned for its educational resources and risk reduction programs. MagMutual provides reliable medical malpractice insurance designed to support and protect healthcare professionals.
  8. ProAssurance Corporation: ProAssurance Corporation specializes in healthcare professional liability insurance, providing reliable and comprehensive coverage solutions. With a strong track record of supporting healthcare providers, ProAssurance emphasizes risk management and patient safety.
  9. Applied Medico-legal Solutions RRG (AMS): Applied Medico-legal Solutions RRG (AMS) offers customized insurance solutions tailored to the needs of various medical specialties. By focusing on the unique risks associated with different areas of practice, AMS provides targeted coverage that meets specific demands.
  10. COPIC: COPIC is a doctor-owned carrier offering regional coverage with a strong commitment to member service. Known for its personalized approach, COPIC provides comprehensive medical malpractice insurance and robust risk management resources.
  11. Hudson Insurance Group: Hudson Insurance Group provides a variety of insurance products, including medical malpractice coverage for doctors. The company’s diverse offerings and focus on quality service make it a dependable choice for healthcare professionals seeking reliable protection.
  12. Aspen Specialty Insurance: Aspen Specialty Insurance caters to the complex needs of medical professional liability by offering excess and surplus coverage. This specialized focus ensures that practitioners with unique or high-risk profiles receive the necessary protection.
  13. Core Specialty Insurance: Core Specialty Insurance offers customizable coverage options for a wide range of healthcare professionals. By providing tailored insurance solutions, Core Specialty ensures that healthcare providers receive comprehensive protection suited to their specific needs.
  14. PRMS/Fair American Insurance and Reinsurance Co (FAIRCO): PRMS/Fair American Insurance and Reinsurance Co (FAIRCO) specializes in providing high-risk insurance solutions for various professions, including doctors. FAIRCO is known for its expertise in managing complex and high-risk profiles, offering tailored insurance products to meet the unique needs of healthcare professionals.
  15. Liberty Mutual Group: Liberty Mutual Group is a major insurance provider that includes medical malpractice coverage as part of its extensive portfolio. Known for its financial strength and broad range of insurance products, Liberty Mutual offers reliable and comprehensive coverage options for healthcare professionals.
  16. Great American Insurance Group: Great American Insurance Group is a diversified insurance company that provides various insurance products, including medical malpractice coverage for doctors.
    With a focus on delivering high-quality service and tailored insurance solutions, Great American supports healthcare professionals with robust protection against liability risks.
  17. Texas Medical Liability Trust (TMLT): Texas Medical Liability Trust (TMLT) is a doctor-owned provider focused on serving the specific needs of Texas physicians. TMLT offers customized medical malpractice insurance and risk management resources to support local healthcare professionals.
  18. Evanston Insurance Company: Evanston Insurance Company offers medical professional liability insurance with a regional focus, providing tailored coverage solutions to meet the needs of healthcare providers in specific areas.
    Known for its localized approach and personalized service, Evanston Insurance ensures that practitioners receive comprehensive protection suited to their regional requirements.
  19. Professional Solutions Insurance Company (PSIC): Professional Solutions Insurance Company (PSIC) provides a range of insurance solutions for various healthcare professions, including medical malpractice coverage. PSIC is recognized for its commitment to delivering high-quality service and tailored insurance products that address the unique needs of healthcare providers.
  20. Medical Mutual Liability Insurance Society of Maryland: Medical Mutual Liability Insurance Society of Maryland is a doctor-owned carrier focused on serving the specific needs of physicians in Maryland. Known for its strong community ties and personalized service, Medical Mutual provides tailored medical malpractice insurance solutions and robust risk management resources.
  21. Physicians Insurance: Physicians Insurance offers medical malpractice coverage with a strong emphasis on risk management and loss prevention. The company is dedicated to supporting healthcare providers through comprehensive insurance solutions and proactive risk reduction strategies.
  22. Curi: Curi is a relatively new carrier that has been gaining traction in the medical malpractice insurance market. Despite its recent entry, Curi has quickly established itself as a provider of reliable and innovative insurance solutions tailored to the needs of healthcare professionals.
  23. State Volunteer Mutual Insurance Company (SVMIC): State Volunteer Mutual Insurance Company (SVMIC) is a doctor-owned provider offering competitive rates and a strong track record in medical malpractice insurance. SVMIC focuses on delivering personalized service and comprehensive coverage to healthcare professionals.
  24. Mutual Insurance Company of Arizona (MICA): Mutual Insurance Company of Arizona (MICA) is a doctor-owned carrier focused on serving the specific needs of physicians in Arizona. MICA provides comprehensive medical malpractice insurance and robust risk management resources to support local healthcare providers.
  25. The SCPIE Companies: The SCPIE Companies is a regional provider offering medical professional liability insurance with a focus on exceptional service. SCPIE is known for its dedicated support to healthcare providers through tailored insurance solutions and proactive risk management initiatives.

Tips for Selecting the Right Medical Malpractice Insurance Company

Choosing the right medical malpractice insurance company is a crucial decision that requires careful consideration. Here are some tips to help you select the best insurance provider for your needs:

  1. Assess your specific needs: Consider your specialty, location, claims history, and the level of coverage you require. This will help you narrow down the insurance companies that offer tailored solutions for your specific circumstances.
  2. Research reputation and financial stability: Look for insurance companies with a strong reputation and a history of financial stability. Check their ratings from reputable agencies to ensure they are reliable and capable of fulfilling their obligations in the event of a malpractice claim.
  3. Compare coverage options and premiums: Evaluate the coverage options offered by different insurance companies, including defense costs, consent-to-settle provisions, and tail coverage. Compare the premiums to ensure you are getting the best value for your money.
  4. Consider customer satisfaction: Read reviews and ratings from other doctors to gauge the level of customer satisfaction with each insurance company. Look for positive feedback regarding claims handling, customer support, and overall experience.
  5. Seek professional advice: Consult with colleagues, professional associations, or insurance brokers who specialize in medical malpractice insurance. Their expertise can provide valuable insights and help you make an informed decision.
  6. Review policy terms and conditions: Carefully read and understand the policy terms and conditions before making a final decision. Pay attention to coverage limits, exclusions, and any additional benefits or discounts offered.
  7. Seek legal counsel if necessary: If you have any doubts or concerns about the insurance policy or its terms, seek legal counsel to ensure you fully understand your rights and obligations.

Conclusion and Final Thoughts

Medical malpractice insurance is essential for physicians nationwide in the USA, offering vital protection against potential claims. We’ve explored the top 24+ providers in the USA for 2024, highlighting key features, premiums, and reviews. 

However, navigating these options alone can be overwhelming. That’s why savvy physicians turn to PLI Consultants. We specialize in securing coverage from top-rated carriers, ensuring competitive rates and personalized service. Contact us at (813) 590-9705 or email info@pliconsultants.com to make an informed choice and focus on providing excellent patient care with peace of mind.

FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions)

Q: Why do doctors need medical malpractice insurance?

A: Medical malpractice insurance protects doctors from financial losses if they are sued for negligence or mistakes during patient care. It covers legal defense costs, settlements, and judgments awarded in malpractice lawsuits.

Q: What factors should I consider when choosing a medical malpractice insurance company?

A: Consider your specific needs (specialty, location, claims history), the company’s reputation and financial strength (AM Best Rating), coverage options (defense costs, settlements, tail coverage), premiums, customer satisfaction reviews, and professional advice from colleagues or brokers.

Q: What are some tips for getting the best deal on medical malpractice insurance?

A: Compare quotes from multiple companies, assess your specific needs to avoid overpaying for unnecessary coverage, and inquire about discounts offered for things like good claims history or participation in risk management programs.

Q: Should I consult a lawyer when reviewing a medical malpractice insurance policy?

A: It’s advisable to carefully review the policy terms and conditions yourself, but if you have any doubts or complexities, consulting a lawyer can ensure you understand your rights and obligations fully.