Medical malpractice insurance is crucial for the safety of healthcare professionals against claims of negligence or errors in patient care. With the constantly changing healthcare scenario, the issues relating to malpractice suits have become very complex, hence the need to have insurance that addresses financial risks.
In this article, we’ll explore some common myths about escalating malpractice premiums, the different factors that affect these rates, and offer some practical tips on how to handle potential increases.
According to data from the reinsurance group TransRe, the trend of high malpractice awards continues to accelerate. In 2023, the average value of the 57 biggest malpractice verdicts exceeded $10 million or more, setting a new record compared to past years. Richard Henderson, who serves as the senior vice president at TransRe, stated this in an interview with Medscape:
“2023 broke all previous records for high malpractice verdicts. When we average the 50 largest verdicts of the year, the amounts are higher than ever before.”
Considering these trends, it’s important for healthcare providers to grasp what’s behind these rising costs and how to manage them efficiently.
Common Myths About Rising Malpractice Insurance Rates
There’s a lot of confusion about malpractice insurance. Let’s clear up some of the most common myths:
- Myth: Premium Increases Are Always the Result of Lawsuits
While lawsuits can drive up premiums, other things like the economy and new healthcare rules often have a big impact on costs.
- Myth: Established Providers Are Immune to Rate Hikes
Even healthcare providers who’ve been around for a while and have clean records can see their premiums go up because of what’s happening in the broader market.
- Myth: Higher Premiums Equate to Better Coverage
Just because a policy carries a higher price tag doesn’t necessarily mean it offers more extensive coverage. It’s crucial to dig into the policy terms instead of just assuming that a higher price equals better quality.
- Myth: Only High-Risk Specialties Face Rising Rates
Yes, high-risk specialties like surgery and obstetrics may see larger increases, but other medical fields are also affected by market trends.
By discarding these myths, healthcare providers can get a clearer view of what really drives their malpractice insurance premiums.
Factors Influencing Malpractice Insurance Premiums
Malpractice insurance rates fluctuate due to several interconnected factors. Here’s a simplified breakdown to help clarify how these factors impact premiums.
-
Overall Market Conditions at the Macro-Level
The overall economic health scores have a big impact on malpractice insurance rates. Insurance companies don’t just take premiums; they use them to invest. When the economy slows down and stock prices drop, their investments might not work as well as they hoped. To cover possible losses, insurers often bump up rates. Other factors like inflation, interest rates, and how stable the economy is also play a role. For instance, when prices are rising fast, it costs more to pay out claims, which pushes rates higher.
-
Claims-Made Insurance Rates Step-up as They Mature
A claims-made medical malpractice insurance policy typically starts with lower premiums that increase annually for the first five years as coverage expands to include past claims. This is due to the gradual expansion of coverage to include claims which may arise in prior years in addition to the current year.
Thus, in the first year, the premium might be $5,000 covering claims only in that year, while in the second year all current claims along with the previous year’s claims become eligible for coverage, increasing the premium to $10,000. This trend continues, with premiums rising as the retroactive coverage period grows—potentially reaching $19,000 by the fifth year.
Once the policy matures, these step-ups stop, and your premiums stabilize. However, they may still be affected by broader market trends or changes in your practice. Understanding this progression helps you anticipate costs as your policy develops.
-
Claims History and Recent Payouts
If you’ve had a malpractice claim or received any indemnity payment over the past five years, you’re probably going to notice a noticeable increase in your insurance premiums compared to someone without recent claims. Insurance companies assess your claims history when determining risk. Even legal fees incurred while defending a claim can influence your premiums. While most insurers do offer good legal representation for their policyholders, the steadily rising costs of legal defense can drive premiums up.
It’s important to keep in mind that even if a claim hasn’t led to a payout yet but is still open, it could still lead to an increase in your rates. Insurance companies consider the potential risks linked to unresolved claims, which means that your premiums can be influenced by both past settlements and any claims still in progress.
-
Changes in Your Practice Profile
Expanding your practice or introducing new procedures directly impacts your malpractice insurance rates. Variables that enter into risk profile consideration include types of procedures, complexities of procedures, and volumes of patients that you actually see. For example, insurers could view an increase in claims opportunities for you if you doubled your patient visits or began performing additional risk procedures; thus, your premiums would be affected as a result of the risk increase.
Your practice’s location also matters as some areas have higher litigation risks. While growth and diversification are great for your practice, they come with added responsibilities—and insurers often respond to this with rising premiums to offset the associated risks.
-
Geographic and Specialty-Specific Factors
Your location and medical specialty significantly influence your insurance premiums. In some areas, there are quite a few more lawsuits or larger payouts when it comes to malpractice claims. This means that doctors in those regions wind up paying more for their insurance coverage. Likewise, some medical specialties come with greater risks than others.
For example, neurosurgeons, obstetricians, and interventional cardiologists typically face higher premiums due to the complexity of their procedures and the elevated risk of malpractice claims.
-
Insurance Market Dynamics
In the end, what determines what you pay for insurance premiums is the competitiveness of the markets of your locality. If only a handful of companies are offering malpractice insurance in your area, they tend to be able to set their rates higher without the pressure of competition to keep them in check. Conversely, in a marketplace where many insurers seek to capture the same clients, the premiums would be expected to go down as companies fight to attract more clients.
Understanding these factors can help you see why malpractice premiums vary so much and why they might increase even if you haven’t had any claims yourself. By knowing what affects your premiums, you can make informed decisions about your coverage and manage your costs more effectively.
Trends Indicating Rising Malpractice Insurance Premiums for 2025
Current trends indicate that malpractice insurance premiums will likely rise in 2025.
Here’s a simple breakdown of why that might happen:
-
Inflation and Economic Uncertainty
With rising costs and an unstable economy, it’s reasonable to think that malpractice insurance premiums will increase. Insurance companies typically invest the premiums they gather to make a profit. When the economy is unstable and those investments struggle, they often hike up premiums to help manage their financial risks.
-
Growing Healthcare Costs
The cost of healthcare keeps going up, and this trend is likely to continue. When healthcare costs rise, the amount of money needed to settle malpractice claims also increases. This could lead to higher premiums because insurance companies need to prepare for larger payouts.
-
Higher Litigation Costs and Bigger Settlements
Malpractice-related expenses are rising, including legal fees, court costs, and expert witness fees. Additionally, jury awards for malpractice cases are reaching record highs. Since insurers are paying out more they’re going to charge higher premiums to make up for it.
-
Changes in the Healthcare Industry
The healthcare industry is changing and that brings new risks. More hospitals and clinics are merging, telemedicine (care through video calls or online) is becoming more common and patients are expecting better care and communication. These changes create challenges for healthcare providers and increase the likelihood of lawsuits which insurers factor in when setting premiums.
-
Cybersecurity Risks and Data Breaches
As electronic health records become more prevalent, the risk of cyberattacks and data breaches in healthcare continues to grow. A cybersecurity breach could result in major financial losses, legal liabilities, and reputational damage for healthcare providers. Due to these threats, insurance companies are taking them into account when determining malpractice insurance rates, which will likely result in higher costs.
In the upcoming years, it is highly likely that malpractice insurance premiums will be on the rise because of an adjustment made by insurers with regard to the increasing risks and costs in the healthcare arena.
Practical Strategies for Managing Malpractice Insurance Costs
Although some factors that influence insurance premiums lie beyond a provider’s control, there are still effective strategies that healthcare professionals can implement to manage these expenses.
-
Proactive Risk Management
Establishing robust risk management policies is crucial. This involves maintaining accurate patient records, ensuring effective communication with patients, adhering to clinical guidelines, and offering continuous risk management training for staff.
-
Focus on Patient Safety and Communication
Prioritizing patient safety and nurturing open lines of communication are essential. By cultivating strong relationships with patients, promptly addressing their concerns, and clearly explaining procedures (and potential risks), healthcare providers can help prevent misunderstandings and reduce the chances of complaints escalating into formal claims.
-
Regularly Compare Insurance Quotes
Instead of sticking with your current insurer, take the time to compare quotes from various reputable insurance companies. This approach will help ensure you’re securing the best rates for the coverage you require.
-
Explore Different Policy Options and Coverage Limits
Familiarize yourself with different policy types, such as claims-made and occurrence-based coverage. Carefully assess coverage limits based on your specialty and location to ensure adequate protection. If you choose a claims-made policy, consider whether you will need tail coverage.
-
Consider Joining Professional Organizations
Many medical professional organizations provide group rates for their members. Being part of these organizations can offer you more affordable options.
-
Maintain Meticulous and Accurate Documentation
Keeping comprehensive and precise medical records is essential for defending against claims. Documenting patient histories, exam results, treatment plans, and communications will strengthen your case if a lawsuit arises.
-
Seek Expert Advice from an Insurance Broker
Working with a medical malpractice insurance broker can simplify the process. They can help you navigate policy complexities, compare options, and secure better rates.
-
Implement Effective Cybersecurity Measures
Patient data must be protected from cyber threats. Investing in solid cyber security measures like firewalls, intrusion detection systems, and regular data backups can reduce the risk of data breaches and the associated liabilities.
Read our blog to learn more about: how medical errors affect your premiums and how to reduce the risk
Rising malpractice insurance premiums can be a source of concern for healthcare providers, but understanding the factors driving these increases and proactively managing risks can help mitigate their impact. By staying informed about market trends, optimizing coverage, and implementing robust risk management practices, providers can navigate the challenges of an evolving insurance landscape while continuing to deliver high-quality care.
